Family Owned, Family Run.

The Paul F. Tilly Agency was founded on January 1st 1979 by Paul Tilly and his wife, Betty Lou.  The original location was the storefront at 1891 Rochester St. in Lima, NY.  Over the next 30 Years, the business continued to grow!

In 2012, The Tilly Agency opened a second office in Avon, NY.

The Paul  F. Tilly Agency, LLC remains committed to its original goals, serving the insurance needs of our customers.  We are a family owned, family run business, committed to providing families with the insurance protection they need. We take the time to listen to your needs, and find the right policy for you.  Your satisfaction is our Number One Priority.  We have built a reputation for client satisfaction, and we are devoted to making your transitional move as easy as possible.

We represent a carefully selected group of financially sound, reputable Insurance Companies; therefore, we are able to offer you the best coverage at a competitive price.

You will have the added benefit of working with agents who understand your needs.  Finding the right policy is only the beginning.  We will assist you every step of the way to ensure smooth sailing.  We look forward to hearing from you!

Celebrating 43 Years!!

Contact Us

**If unable to contact Avon office,
please call the Lima office
you will be transferred to an agent in Avon**

Lima Office
Phone Number: (585) 582-1660
Fax Number: (585) 582-1018

Avon Office
Phone Number: (585) 226-2021
Fax Number: (585) 226-2111

Company Claim Phone Numbers

Make A Payment

Manage Your Policy Online

Request A Quote!

Find Local Glass & Repair Shops

Upcoming Events/Defensive Driver Courses

What’s New?
Check Out Our Community Page!